Mexico: the long road to tobacco control

Mexico: the long road to tobacco control

In 2004, Mexico became the first country in the Americas to ratify the landmark WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, but it would take another 20 years before its measures became enshrined in Mexican law. “When you’re up against one of the biggest, most powerful industries in the world, endurance, persistence, and collaboration are the only ways forward,” said Dr. Juan Arturo Sabines, Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) National Consultant on tobacco control.

Tobacco use is the single most preventable cause of death in the world today, killing nearly one million people in the Americas each year, either through direct consumption or exposure to second-hand smoke. It accounts for 15% of deaths from cardiovascular disease, 24% of deaths from cancer, and 45% of deaths from chronic respiratory disease.

“The case against tobacco began in the 1950’s when the medical community started collecting evidence that smoking causes serious disease, particularly cancer,” said Adriana Bacelar Gomes, Tobacco Surveillance Specialist at PAHO. “That’s when the first initiatives started to limit the industry and regulate tobacco products and their use, and that’s when our work began.”

Sixty years later, however, tobacco remains the only legal consumer product that kills up to half of its users.

WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC)

Over the past 20 years, PAHO’s work on tobacco control has focused primarily on supporting countries in their efforts to adopt and implement the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC), an international, legally binding treaty which promotes cost-effective tobacco control measures. These include protection from second-hand smoke in all indoor workplaces and public spaces; large graphic health warnings on the packaging of tobacco products; a comprehensive ban on tobacco advertising, promotion, and sponsorship; and raising taxes on tobacco products.

While these measures make perfect sense in terms of protecting public health and reducing the impact on health systems, strong industry resistance has resulted in delays in implementing them, often for many years.

“When it comes to tobacco control, there is a very powerful, well-resourced industry working directly against public health. And they’re prepared to use everything in their arsenal to prevent reducing demand for their products, which is a key public health goal,” said Bacelar Gomes.

In the case of Mexico, the first concrete action following the ratification of the WHO FCTC, was the passing of the general tobacco control law in 2008.

“This law adopted the measures of the WHO FCTC, but only partially,” Sabines said. “For example, while it proposed smoke-free public places, it still allowed for designated areas where people could smoke indoors, which fails to protect the public from second-hand smoke.”

PAHO’s efforts over the next 13 years were crucial to getting the law amended. This included ongoing technical support to the Mexican Ministry of Health; capacity building; the development and dissemination of scientific evidence to support the measures; as well as communication campaigns to inform the public of the harms of tobacco use.

More recently, technical cooperation has included efforts to help prevent young people from using novel products, such as e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products, that are aggressively marketed as “healthier alternatives”.

Between 2008 and 2021, when the law was amended, there were over 100 initiatives in Congress to update the tobacco control law. “These included initiatives to improve the legislation on packaging and advertising, smoke-free public places,” Sabines said. But none of them came to fruition.

During this time, the PAHO country office organized meetings with national and international partners, technical experts, and officials from the Ministry of Health to devise a strategy that would enable the country to advance the amendment of the tobacco control law. This included work with national media to publish articles and editorials on the importance of tobacco control.

COVID-19 adds urgency to tobacco control

The link between tobacco consumption and NCDs could no longer be ignored once the pandemic started. COVID-19 was killing people of the Americas in their thousands, and those with pre-existing conditions, particularly chronic respiratory disease and other diseases caused by smoking, were disproportionately impacted.

“While it was difficult during the pandemic to focus attention on public health issues other than COVID-19, the importance of implementing stringent public health policies to protect populations from unhealthy products such as tobacco became immediately obvious,” stated Luciana Severini, PAHO International Consultant on tobacco control.

The diligent and persistent work of PAHO and the tobacco control community finally paid off when the Mexican Senate unanimously approved the amendment of the General Law for Tobacco Control – establishing 100% smoke-free environments and a total ban on the advertising, promotion, and sponsorship of tobacco products on December 14, 2021.

“This amendment represents a historic step forward for Mexico in its anti-smoking policies and reaffirms its role as one of the leaders in the fight against tobacco in the world,” Cristian Morales, former PAHO/WHO Representative Mexico.

While Mexico is one of the countries in the region that successfully put laws in place to protect people from the harmful impact of tobacco use, much remains to be done to reduce the risk factors for non-communicable diseases, such as smoking, in the Americas.

PAHO continues to work with Member States to address NCDs including through the development of policy and legislation, the provision of guidelines for NCD management, surveillance and monitoring, capacity building and through advocacy and awareness-raising.

Source: PAHO